Best Desktop Humidors for Cigars – Buyer’s Guide

best desktop cigar humidorsBet you didn’t know this one! Cigar smoking entered the mainstream of our culture thanks to the efforts of one Christopher Columbus. Upon seeing the natives of the Caribbean smoking dried tobacco leaves during his visit, old Chris and his men gave it a try. They were so impressed that they brought tobacco back with them to Spain, and soon enough cigar rolling was perfected, and cigar smoking spread around the world.

As with just about anything, cigar quality will vary quite a bit. It’s generally acknowledged that the best tobaccos come from Brazil, Cuba, the Dominican Republic, and Honduras. Virtually everyone acknowledges that hand-rolled cigars are superior to machine-rolled. But now that you’ve found the perfect cigar, where will you keep them? A humidor, of course. A dried-out cigar will burn quicker, crack, and lose flavor. A humidor will keep your cigar moist, fresh, and extend the period of storage almost indefinitely.

Best Choice
Case Elegance Cedar Humidor
Case Elegance Cedar Humidor
Best Handmade Cigar Humidor
Read Customer Reviews

In this product review, we’ll look at ten different desktop cigar humidors. These humidors are all available through Amazon.com, and we’ve even included a link for you in the comparison table below. We’ll give you a detailed review of each humidor, including the best features, pros and cons, and a general conclusion on the merits of each humidor. We’ll also give you a quick overview lesson on a cigar cutter, a tool you can’t do without as a cigar smoker.

Best Desktop Humidors 2020 (Updated March, 2020)

Product Product Information View on Amazon
Editor’s Choice

Glass Top Handcrafted Cedar Humidor with Front Digital Hygrometer, Humidifier Gel, and Accessory Drawer

1. Case Elegance

  • Best Features:
    – glass top for attractive display,
    – built-in digital hygrometer for humidity readings,
    – drawer for accessory storage,
    – magnetic seal
  • Cigar Capacity: 25-50
  • Dimensions: 9 x 8.5 x 5.4 in
  • Materials: Spanish Cedar Lining

Check Price

Quality Importers El Rey Desktop Cigar Humidor, Mahogany Finish, Spanish Cedar Tray & Divider

2. El Rey

  • Best Features:
    – attractive scrolled mahogany finish,
    – gold plated lock and key,
    – two humidifiers,
    – divided bottom
  • Cigar Capacity: 150
  • Dimensions: 9.8 x 14.2 x 6.2 in
  • Materials: Spanish Cedar Lining

Check Price

Mantello Large Glass-Top Cigar Humidor Humidifier Box with Hygrometer and Cedar Tray

3. Mantello

  • Best Features:
    – removable tray with divider,
    – lock and key included,
    – tempered glass top,
    – solid brass hinges
  • Cigar Capacity: 100
  • Dimensions: 13.5 x 9.4 x 6.3 in
  • Materials: Mahogany with Spanish Cedar inner lining

Check Price

Carbon Fiber Design Handcrafted Modern Cedar Humidor with Front Digital Hygrometer and Humidifier Gel

4. Case Elegance Carbon Fiber

  • Best Features:
    – modern carbon-fiber exterior designed,
    with standard cedar lined interior,
    – built-in digital hygrometer,
    – polished steel clip for monogramming
  • Cigar Capacity: 25-50
  • Dimensions: 9 x 8.5 x 3.6 in
  • Materials: Spanish Cedar Lining, carbon-fiber exterior

Check Price

MEGACRA Desktop Cigar Humidor, Cedar & Leather Cigar Storage Box Well Seal Design with Tray and Adjustable Divider

5. MEGACRA

  • Best Features:
    – hand-made cedar and leather
    construction,
    – tray and adjustable divider,
    – glass hygrometer,
    – rectangular humidifier
  • Cigar Capacity: 25-50
  • Dimensions: 10.4×8.9×4.6 in
  • Materials: Spanish Cedar Lining, PU Leather Finish

Check Price

Cigar Humidor Handmade Wood Cigar Box Desktop Humidor with Hygrometer and Humidifier

6. Gaoduan

  • Best Features:
    – glass top,
    – inlaid gold-plated hinges,
    – adjustable divider,
    – hygrometer, and humidifier
    included,
    – strong seal scratch-resistant
    pad
  • Cigar Capacity: 20-25
  • Dimensions: 10.2x 8.7×2.7 In
  • Materials: Spanish Cedar Lining

Check Price

Quality Importers Trading Deauville 100 Cigar Humidor, High Gloss with Tobacco Leaf Inlay

7. Deauville

  • Best Features:
    – large capacity, up to 150 cigars,
    – high gloss maple wood finish
    with tobacco leaf inlay,
    – SureSeal technology,
    – brass hardware,
    – lock, and key
  • Cigar Capacity: 100-150
  • Dimensions: 13.5 x 9.5 x 6.5 in
  • Materials: Spanish Cedar Lining

Check Price

Desktop Humidor, Capri, with Tempered Glasstop, Cedar Divider, and Brass Ring Glass Hygrometer

8. Capri

  • Best Features:
    – tempered glass top,
    – brass-ringed glass hygrometer,
    – round and front-mounted,
    – felt-lined bottom,
    – cedar divider,
    – customizable and engravable
    nameplate
  • Cigar Capacity: 20-50
  • Dimensions: 8.8 x 10.5 x 4.5 in
  • Materials: Spanish Cedar Lining

Check Price

Quality Importers Trading Milano Cigar Humidor, Rosewood, Spanish Cedar Tray with Divider

9. Milano

  • Best Features:
    – rosewood finish exterior,
    – cedar lined interior,
    – gold plated lock, key,
    and hardware,
    – SureSeal technology,
    – round hygrometer and humidifier
  • Cigar Capacity: 75-100
  • Dimensions: 14 x 9.5 x 6.5 in
  • Materials: Spanish Cedar Interior Lining

Check Price

Old Glory Cigar Humidor, Weathered American Flag Exterior

10. Old Glory

  • Best Features:
    – weathered American
    flag exterior,
    – glass hygrometer,
    – rectangular humidifier,
    – cedar tray with divider,
    – lock and key,
    – scratch-resistant bottom
  • Cigar Capacity: 75-100
  • Dimensions: 14 x 9.5 x 6.5 in
  • Materials: Spanish Cedar Interior lining

Check Price

Great Bonus

ALASKA BEAR-Cigar Cutter Stainless Steel Guillotine Double Cut Blade in Black Gift Pouch

11. ALASKA BEAR

  • Hole diameter: 0.892 inch
  • Color:
    – Antique Bronze;
    – Gun Black;
    – Stainless Steel
  • Best Features:
    – self-sharpening double blades,
    – brushed steel finish,
    – cuts all sized cigars
    up to 60 gauge

Check Price

Best Cigar Humidor Reviews

1. Case Elegance – Best Handmade Cigar Humidor

Glass Top Handcrafted Cedar Humidor with Front Digital Hygrometer, Humidifier Gel, and Accessory Drawer

General impression

This humidor is an excellent combination of hand-crafted elegance and functionality. The tempered glass top and dark walnut finish will make it an attractive complement to any desktop. The front-facing, built-in hygrometer, enclosed in brass hardware, completes the look. An accessory drawer adds to the basic functionality, and magnetic seals effectively prevent air movement, and won’t compromise the interior humidity and freshness of your cigars.

Best Features

  • The digital hygrometer is an accurate measure of humidity and seasoning of the humidor.
  • It has a low-maintenance system, comprised of humidifying gel and hydro sticks (included) to maintain a constant relative humidity of 65 – 70%, with firm magnetic sealing to hold it at that level.
  • It’s the #2 selling humidor at Amazon and has almost four hundred customer ratings.
Pros
  • Large glass top gives an excellent display of your cigar collection
  • Digital hygrometer for accuracy
Cons
  • Some reviewers claim cigar storage capability is over-stated (see cigar gauge in buyer’s guide)
  • Some users had difficulty getting humidor to required humidity during initial seasoning

Conclusion

If you are looking for an elegant humidor to fit in with any room décor, this is the one. It’s extremely attractive, and the handmade detail and functionality should serve you for years to come. It’s highly rated overall, but especially high for value and craftsmanship.

View On Amazon

2. El Rey – Best Quality Cigar Humidor

Quality Importers El Rey Desktop Cigar Humidor, Mahogany Finish, Spanish Cedar Tray & Divider

General impression

Mix a beautiful mahogany finish with an elegant scalloped design, finished off with gold-plated hardware, and you get the El Rey humidor. With a tray and divider, this humidor has capacity for up to one-hundred-fifty cigars. The round hygrometer and two humidifiers are visible through the tempered glass top, making this a fully functional, as well as a high quality humidor.

Best Features

  • The top tray is divided, allowing you to separate the various brands of cigars you keep.
  • The bottom storage is also divided, and made from Spanish cedar for an excellent aroma and moisture retention.
  • The felt-lined bottom is scratch-resistant, and the humidor comes with a lock and key set.
Pros
  • SureSeal technology ensures a proper lid closure with no air leaks
  • Highly rated for accuracy and craftsmanship
Cons
  • Some complaints about damage to the humidor as the result of packaging and shipping process

Conclusion

Customer reviews consistently point out the quality of the humidor, the finish, and the look. It’s fully functional, and also well put together. The mahogany finish adds a nice final touch to the quality of this humidor. The high craftsmanship rating is indicative of the overall quality of this humidor.

View On Amazon

3. Mantello – Best Cigar Humidor Under $100

Mantello Large Glass-Top Cigar Humidor Humidifier Box with Hygrometer and Cedar Tray

General impression

With a rated capacity of from fifty to one-hundred cigars, this humidor is a great value for the price. With a full Spanish cedar interior, you also get an exterior mounted hygrometer, humidifiers, and a tray with divider. The tempered glass top and brass hardware top off a lavish look.

Best Features

  • As an Amazon Choice product, you know that you will get a well-priced, highly rated product, and this humidor will not disappoint.
  • The brass hinges and hardware provide a nice contrast to the deep mahogany wood finish.
Pros
  • Highly rated for quality and durability
  • High capacity for the big-time cigar smoker
Cons
  • Several reviewers had difficulty getting the humidity up to appropriate level during initial seasoning
milano cigar humidor

Conclusion

If you need a higher capacity, fully functional, good-looking humidor for your cigars, and don’t want to spend a ton of money, this is the one for you. It’s an Amazon Choice and a top twenty seller, giving you full features and expansive storage at a bargain price.

View On Amazon

4. Case Elegance Carbon Fiber – Best Modern Cigar Humidor

Carbon Fiber Design Handcrafted Modern Cedar Humidor with Front Digital Hygrometer and Humidifier Gel

General impression

This is another Case Elegance humidor, and moves away from the standard wood and glass humidors we’ve seen so far. Featuring the same Spanish cedar interior as other models, this humidor moves into a neo-modern look with a carbon fiber exterior design. It has many of the same features as other Case products, including a patent-pending design that maintains humidity from 65 – 70%.

Best Features

  • The sleek, modern exterior is embellished with a polished stainless steel plate suitable for engraving or monogramming.
  • The pre-calibrated digital hygrometer is centered on the front panel of the humidor, making it easy to monitor the interior humidity, and the magnetic seal helps to hold it constant.
  • The humidor comes with a humidifying kit containing humidifying gel and hydro sticks for the initial seasoning of the box.
Pros
  • Unique, attractive design to fit in with a modern décor
  • Excellent customer ratings for hygrometer accuracy and overall value
Cons
  • As with some other models, initial seasoning and building humidity may prove difficult

Conclusion

If you are looking for a humidor that is both fully functional and decorative in a modern décor, you should consider this carbon fiber designed humidor. You get the same interior wood and function as with other models, but it’s encased in a sleek, dark carbon fiber look. As a decorative piece, it is a step up over other humidors.

View On Amazon

5. MEGACRA – Best Humidor for the Money

MEGACRA Desktop Cigar Humidor, Cedar & Leather Cigar Storage Box Well Seal Design with Tray and Adjustable Divider

General impression

Take a full-function humidor, and encase it in leather, and you get a luxury cigar storage box for your desktop. Factor in a bargain price and high-quality ratings, and you get a “best value” humidor. The hygrometer and humidifier help to control the humidity inside and the WellSeal design gives a tight seal to hold the relative humidity constant.

Best Features

  • The removable tray and adjustable divider make this an excellent container for holding your cigar collection, with a capacity of 25 – 50 cigars.
  • The artificial leather exterior gives the humidor a sophisticated look, and the embedded hinges and interior design make it fully functional and easily adjustable.
  • An included care and instructional manual makes this an excellent investment for the novice cigar smoker.
Pros
  • Almost 150 customer ratings; highly rated for craftsmanship and value for the money
  • Budget-priced with several upper-end features, suitable for the novice or experienced smoker
Cons
  • Hygrometer is mounted inside the top cover, so cannot be monitored without opening the humidor

Conclusion

If your definition of value is excellent quality, full features and specifications, and a fair price, then this is your humidor. You get similar performance and features to other, more expensive humidors, for a lot less money. The leather exterior gives it an attractive look, just right for a prominent spot on your desk.

View On Amazon

6. Gaoduan – Best Small Humidor for Cigars

Cigar Humidor Handmade Wood Cigar Box Desktop Humidor with Hygrometer and Humidifier

General impression

If you have a larger humidor, but a smaller collection of cigars, it may be more difficult to maintain the required humidity, due to the greater amount of air in the humidor. To help with this issue, Gaoduan has introduced a series of differently sized humidors to more closely match capacity to your cigar collection size. These smaller humidors have all the features of larger humidors and give good value for the money.

Best Features

  • Sized for twenty to twenty-five cigars, this humidor comes with a humidifier, hygrometer, and adjustable partition for the humidor.
  • It has a velvet-backed bottom to prevent scratching, and a nicely grained, dark wood finish with a tempered glass top.
  • Gold-plated hardware adds an attractive finishing touch.
Pros
  • Four models available, so the humidor can be sized to perfectly fit your cigar collection
  • Well-rated for overall quality, value for the money, and accuracy
Cons
  • As with some other models, initial seasoning and building humidity may prove difficult

Cigar Humidor Handmade Wood

Conclusion

Why pay for size you don’t need? If you expect to grow your cigar collection in the future, by all means, buy a larger humidor. But if your cigar collection size is where it will stay, why not buy a humidor perfectly sized for that? With four models available, you can choose the one best suited for you.

View On Amazon

7. Deauville – Best Engravable Cigar Humidor

Quality Importers Trading Deauville 100 Cigar Humidor, High Gloss with Tobacco Leaf Inlay

General impression

This humidor just exudes class, starting with a beautiful maple wood finish, moving to the inlaid tobacco leaf on the top, and ending with an engravable brass plate to personalize your cigar storage. Topped off with brass hardware and lock and key, this full-function humidor has a large storage capacity in addition to the good looks.

Best Features

  • With a rated capacity of one hundred or more cigars, this humidor will easily store your collection.
  • It has a removable, divided tray, and has two additional dividers in the bottom storage section for improved organization and space utilization.
  • The brass and glass hygrometer, coupled with a rectangular humidifier, give you excellent humidity control.
Pros
  • Highly rated for craftsmanship, accuracy, and material quality
  • Large storage capacity of up to 150 cigars, depending on cigar gauge and length (see Buyer’s guide)
Cons
  • Hygrometer magnet fell off for some reviewers; had to be glued in place as the magnet was thought to be too weak

Conclusion

Cigar smokers are known for their individualism. And what better way to display that individualism by adding a personalized, brass engraving to their humidor? The humidor is attractive on its own, with the inlaid tobacco leaf adding a unique touch, but the engraved brass plate will put this humidor over the top while displayed on your desktop at home or in the office.

View On Amazon

8. Capri – Best Rated Cigar Humidor

Desktop Humidor, Capri, with Tempered Glasstop, Cedar Divider, and Brass Ring Glass Hygrometer

General impression

This smaller humidor, geared for twenty-five to fifty cigars, comes in a deep mahogany finish and is lined with kiln-dried Spanish cedar. The external glass hygrometer has brass details, and the humidor comes with gold-plated hardware and a brass plate suitable for engraving. With over two thousand reviews, it is well-rated and perfect for the novice or experienced cigar smoker.

Best Features

  • The mahogany finish is set off with a tempered glass top, and the bottom is covered with a scratch-resistant felt material.
  • The front mount hygrometer allows you to monitor humidity without opening the humidor.
  • The brass ring around the hygrometer adds to the elegant look of this humidor.
Pros
  • High ratings for being giftable, sturdy, and craftsmanship
  • SureSeal closure technology gives a superior seal to protect from air leakage and humidity variation
Cons
  • Dividers are cedar veneer, not full cedar wood

Conclusion

With over 2000 reviewers giving this humidor solid ratings, you can be sure that you are getting a solidly functioning humidor. With a budget price to accompany the quality ratings, you really can’t go wrong with this product. The ratings and value make it a perfect choice as a small humidor.

View On Amazon

9. Milano – Best Large Cigar Humidors

Quality Importers Trading Milano Cigar Humidor, Rosewood, Spanish Cedar Tray with Divider

General impression

With a one hundred cigar capacity, this humidor comes in a beautifully grained rosewood finish, with a gold-plated lock and key. The hygrometer and humidifier are interior mounted, leaving the outside with clean, angular lines. SureSeal closure technology gives the user confidence that the proper levels of humidity will be maintained.

Best Features

  • The rolling rosewood grain pattern gives this humidor a simple, subtle elegance and beauty, nicely set off by the gold lock and tasseled key.
  • It’s also available in a cherry finish, and either finish comes with an engravable brass nameplate.
  • Functionally, it has everything you need for cigar storage, including the large, one hundred cigar capacity.
Pros
  • Large capacity, but without a boxy look to the humidor; nicely proportioned width and depth
  • SureSeal technology provides an effective seal against air leakage
Cons
  • Some reviewers report difficulty with initial seasoning of the humidor

Conclusion

Rosewood has a very subtle yet distinct grain pattern, making this a very attractive humidor. These good looks, combined with a one hundred cigar capacity, make this an excellent choice for a large cigar humidor.

View On Amazon

10. Old Glory– Best American Made Cigar Humidor

Old Glory Cigar Humidor, Weathered American Flag Exterior

General impression

If you are into Americana, this humidor will be just perfect for your home or office décor. Featuring the look of a weathered American flag, it will hold up to one hundred cigars. The hygrometer and humidifier mount to the internal Spanish cedar lining, and SureSeal technology keeps the humidity at the proper level. A tray with an adjustable divider and a tarnished brass lock and tasseled key close out the functionality.

Best Features

  • The antique flag design is a nice variation from the typical wood humidors, and makes a great statement piece in any décor or area.
  • The felt-lined bottom prevents scratching and the kiln-dried Spanish cedar interior and try provides functional storage.
Pros
  • Unique, attractive design on this humidor
  • Solid reviews for accuracy, craftsmanship, and value for money
Cons
  • Some customers noted that warranty and support contact information was dated and did not work

Conclusion

If you like to smoke cigars, and you like to display Old Glory and Americana, then this humidor is exactly what you need. American designed and made to exacting specifications, it’s fully functional, seals well, and holds a lot of cigars.

View On Amazon

Bonus Product Review – Alaska Bear Cigar Cutter

ALASKA BEAR-Cigar Cutter Stainless Steel Guillotine Double Cut Blade in Black Gift Pouch

General Impression

If you’re going to invest money in good cigars and a good humidor, you don’t want to ruin your smoke by using an inferior cigar cutter. We recommend the Alaska Bear cigar cutter. You can find the Amazon link in the comparison table above. Produced from brushed stainless steel, it has self-sharpening double blades to cut your cigars cleanly and precisely. It works on all cigars up to sixty gauge.

alaska bear cigar cutter

View On Amazon

Buyer’s Guide

In this section, we’ll give you some additional information about key specifications, features, and terms you may run across when deciding on a desktop cigar humidor. This knowledge will help you make a more informed buying decision and get the best value and features for your money. We also encourage you to do additional research on either Amazon or the manufacturer’s web sites.

Initial Seasoning

Hygrometer

HygrometerA hygrometer is used to measure the amount of humidity and water vapor in the air, typically within a confined space, such as a humidor. Cigars need to be kept within a relative humidity range of 65 – 70%. If the humidity is lower, they will dry and have a tendency to crack. If humidity is too high, you will get an inconsistent burn of the tobacco. Hygrometers may be built into the humidor or may be a separate unit not integrated into the humidor.

Initial Seasoning

Initial Seasoning

Most humidors will have an interior lining of Spanish cedar. This wood is excellent at retaining moisture, yet remains mold and mildew resistant at these somewhat higher levels of humidity. Some humidors will contain special kits to aid in the initial seasoning, often containing a humidor solution or hydrogel solution. You can also do the initial seasoning with plain old distilled water. Click on the link to an excellent article on the initial seasoning of a humidor. The most important thing is to get the wood’s humidity to the right level to protect the cigarsbefore storing them in the humidor.

Ring Gauge for Cigars

Ring Gauge for Cigars

When sizing a humidor for the number of cigars it will hold, you may see references to both length and ring gauge. Obviously, the longer or thicker the cigar, the fewer that the humidor will hold. Cigar length is measured in inches, so no great mystery there. The longer the cigar, the cooler the smoke. Gauge is measured in 1/64-inch increments. Therefore a 64-gauge cigar will be one inch in diameter, 32-gauge ½”, and so on. The thicker the cigar, the fuller the flavor.

Humidifiers

Humidifiers

humidifiers for cigar humidorHumidifiers are used in humidors to help maintain the internal humidity to a specific level to maintain cigar quality. Typically, this will be 65 – 70% relative humidity. There are two primary types of humidifiers. Active humidifiers will have a reservoir for water storage, circulation fan, and hydrostat to add water as needed. Active humidifiers are normally found on larger humidors, right up to walk-in sizes. Passive humidifiers are more likely to be found with desktop humidors. They are typically made of an absorbent or sponge-like material that releases water into the air as it evaporates. Water will occasionally need to be added to passive humidifiers.

Sealing the Humidor

Sealing the Humidor

Without a good seal, it will be impossible to regulate and maintain the humidity level inside the humidor. In the product review, you will see a couple of different technology references for the seal type in a humidor. One very simple test of a humidor’s seal is the “dollar bill test.” Put a dollar bill half inside and half outside the humidor and pull on it. It should be very difficult, if not impossible, to pull out the bill without ripping it if you have a good seal on your humidor.


Conclusion

We hope that this product review for the best desktop humidors has been a good primer for you and given you sufficient information to make a best-value purchase of your humidor. The different styles, sizes, appearances presented here should give you a broad overview of the humidor market and hopefully helped shape your needs analysis and purchasing decision.

To wrap up this review, Sigmund Freud is often credited with saying,

“Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.”

While Dr. Freud may have known psychology well, he obviously did not know cigars so well. Check out this link, and you will see there is no way that these ten samples are “just a cigar.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *